SEJ
Published on SEJ (https://www.sej.org)

Home > "Is the USDA Silencing Scientists?"

"Is the USDA Silencing Scientists?" [1]

"“There's a message: If you want to prosper, don't make waves.”"

"Late last year, Jonathan Lundgren, a South Dakota-based entomologist with the U.S. Department of Agriculture, submitted an article to the scientific journal Naturwissenschaften. It described how clothianidin—one of a controversial class of pesticides called neonicotinoids—harmed monarch butterflies. The paper was accepted. Then, in February, a supervisor confronted Lundgren. She informed him that the paper shouldn't have been submitted without official approval. It was sensitive.

Not long after, the National Academy of Sciences scheduled Lundgren to give a presentation on the effects of genetically modified crops on farmland ecology. As is customary, the NAS would pay for his travel to Washington, D.C. Lundgren accepted, but didn't complete the requisite agency paperwork—something that's technically against the rules, but not unusual, with scientists instead filing when they return. Lundgren was reportedly boarding the plane when instructed to return home and reimburse airfare costs out of his own pocket.

In August the USDA formally suspended Lundgren for these transgressions. But according to Lundgren, he wasn't punished for breaking a few rules. Instead, he says, the very agency responsible for America's farms and food punished him for his science."

Brandon Keim reports for The Atlantic November 3, 2015. [2]

Chemicals [3]
Environmental Politics [4]
Science [5]
National (U.S.) [6]
Public [7]
Source: Atlantic [2], 11/05/2015
  • Contact Us  |
  • Donate  |
  • Join  |
  • Members  |
  • Privacy & Security Policies  |
  • Reach SEJ Members  |
  • Renew  |
  • Site Map
The Society of Environmental Journalists
1629 K Street NW, Suite 300, Washington, DC 20006
Telephone: (202) 558-2055
Email: sej@sej.org
© 2026 The Society of Environmental Journalists. All Rights Reserved.
All graphics © SEJ, unless otherwise stated.

Source URL:https://www.sej.org/headlines/usda-silencing-scientists

Links
[1] https://www.sej.org/headlines/usda-silencing-scientists [2] http://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2015/11/is-the-usda-silencing-scientists/413803/ [3] https://www.sej.org/category/topics-beat/chemicals/toxics [4] https://www.sej.org/category/topics-beat/environmental-politics [5] https://www.sej.org/category/topics-beat/science [6] https://www.sej.org/category/region/national [7] https://www.sej.org/taxonomy/term/81